Thursday, July 11, 2013

Environmentalists dirty little secret, rare earth elements



So called 'green' technologies are in fact not green at all. We have been mislead into thinking we are doing a good deed for the plant by using a compact fluorescent light bulb, buying a hybrid car, using wind and solar energy. Meanwhile these technologies require rare earth elements and the process of extracting them is extremely harmful to the environment and human health. We are replacing one environmental problem with another. Rare earth elements are found in many modern day conveniences, smart phones, lap tops, tvs, we need to develop better methods of recycling these elements and methods of producing 'green' technologies that truly are green.


Please sign and share the petition 

Join the conversation on Facebook


Follow on Twitter

Matamec - Kipawa Mine Project - English Version



The only thing 'green' about this project are the products produced using the rare earth elements. What the video fails to include is the fact that several trucks of acid will be required per day for the processing - the acid will be transported by truck from Ontario, through North Bay and along the HWY 63 corridor and then along the Maniwaki road putting other watersheds as risk should an accident occur. The project will require 190-210 meters cubed of fresh water per hour! Effluent will be released into the nearby water bodies. Wetlands will be transferred into tailings sites which will require careful monitoring well after Matamec has made their money and moved on. The project will produce more than 40 million tonnes of waste and tailings including 600 tonnes of Uranium Oxide and 5,000-8,000 tones of Thorium Oxide both of which remain active for tens of thousands of years. They also generate over 30 other radioactive substances as they undergo radioactive decay. Of course Matamec's video makes no mention of the risks to the local environment or the local population. Some risks include contamination of air, soil and water by heavy metals and radioactive substances. Destruction of important wildlife areas, habitat, destruction of fish habitat, fish spawning grounds, increased cancer rates amount local residents. They also make no mention of non-environmentally friendly uses of rare earth elements or the fact that not one rare earth mine has ever operated in the world without serious environmental and human health consequences.


Please sign and share the petition 

Join the conversation on Facebook


Follow on Twitter


Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Appeal for a provincial environmental impact assessment

La coalition pour que le Quebec ait meilleure mine appeals to M. Yves-François Blanchet 
Ministre responsable du Développement durable, de l’Environnement, de la Faune et des Parcs for provincial environmental impact assessment. Due to the tonnage extract per day (under 7000 tonnes) the project does not trigger a Quebec environmental impact assessment. Matamec was asked to voluntarily submit to a provincial assessment, their response was that they would do only what was legally required.

http://www.miningwatch.ca/sites/www.miningwatch.ca/files/2013-05-23-lettreministreblanchet-minesterresrares.pdf


Please sign and share the petition 

Join the conversation on Facebook


Follow on Twitter

North Bay Nugget - Rare Earths Mine Under Scrutiny

http://www.nugget.ca/2013/06/11/rare-earths-mine-under-scrutiny

Mr. Claude Brisson Director of Regional Relations for Matamec was interviewed, these were his statements:


“I realize people are concerned” about the project, Claude Brisson, director of regional relations, said Tuesday. “They are concerned about the water quality” of Kipawa Lake.
“I live on the lake.”
The processing plant was moved away from the open pit location, Brisson said, so the nearby waterways, including the Kipawa River, will be protected.
There will also be a tailings site to take the waste from the treated ore. It will also be well away from the waterways, Brisson said, and will be easy to treat.
“What we don’t want, is . . . something that we will have to take care of for a long, long time” after the mine’s projected 15 to 16 years of operation.

I think perhaps Mr. Brisson himself is not fully aware and seriously misinformed about the risks of this project. If he lives on the lake he should be concerned. Moving the processing plant and tailings sites further away from the water bodies in no way guarantees their protection. All sites as still located within the Kipawa Lake Catchment Basin, meaning all run off waters from the mine, spills, etc. will make their way into Kipawa Lake. Since when are mine tailings easy to treat? Mine tailings often contain heavy metals, and radioactive substances. They are something that you have to take care of for a long, long time, well after the projected 15-16 years of operation.

 This project will produce more than 40 million tonnes of waste and tailings including 600 tonnes of Uranium Oxide and 5,000-8,000 tonnes of Thorium Oxide. Both of which remain active for tens of thousands of years and generate over 30 other radioactive byproducts as they undergo radioactive decay. The tailings sites will have to be properly managed for a very long time. Mining companies do not stick around to do this job of clean up and management of their wastes. It falls upon the government to clean up their mess and tax payer money is used to that end. End of the day, Matamec and Toyota make a ton of money off of this project (billions of dollars), they destroy the land, the community makes very little, they are able to tax any buildings but mining operations don't have many buildings. The project might employ a few local residents but the majority of positions will not go to local residents. Then when the mining company is finished extracting Canada's natural resources they pick up and leave. The Canadian government is not paid for the ores they extract but is then responsible to clean up the mess. 



Please sign and share the petition 

Join the conversation on Facebook


Follow on Twitter


Petition Media Coverage by Radio Canada

Within the first few days of the petition going live there were over 600 signatures and CBC Radio Canada for the Abitibi-Temiscaming included the petition in their news broadcast.

http://www.radio-canada.ca/audio-video/pop.shtml#urlMedia=http://www.radio-canada.ca/Medianet/2013/CBF_Rouyn/BulletinRegionalCBFRouyn201306061400.asx

http://www.radio-canada.ca/audio-video/pop.shtml#urlMedia=http://www.radio-canada.ca/Medianet/2013/CBF_Rouyn/Leradiomagazine201306061636.asx

http://www.radio-canada.ca/regions/abitibi/2013/06/07/001-petition-lac-kipawa.shtml


Please sign and share the petition 

Join the conversation on Facebook


Follow on Twitter

SAVE KIPAWA LAKE



Please sign and share the petition 

Join the conversation on Facebook


Follow on Twitter

Monday, July 8, 2013

Kipawa Lake Today

Kipawa Lake is part of a vast area of wilderness located on the Quebec side of the Ontario/Quebec border North of Ottawa and North-East of North Bay, Ontario. This area is accessible via HWY 63 which runs from North Bay to Temiscaming, Quebec.



View Larger Map

Thousands visit this area every year to hunt, fish, explore, canoe, kayak and vacation. With the exception of the more populated sections of the lake (which are found in Kipawa, Laniel, Mungo Bay and Red Pine Chutes) the shores of  Kipawa Lake are undeveloped with only the occasional cottage, cabin or fishing lodge. A moratorium on development was imposed in the 1980s preventing any new lots from being sold and putting a limit on outfitting operations. The purpose was to help protect the lake trout fishery which was on the verge of collapse. This moratorium has helped keep Kipawa Lake a wilderness area while many other lakes of its size in the past 30 years have become overdeveloped.




This area is rich in biodiversity, it is home to over 200 different species of plants. Trees in the area include white pine, red pine, white birch, yellow birch, maple, spruce, cedar, aspen, hemlock and many others. Many mammals can be found in this region including beaver, white-tailed deer, moose, black bear, lynx, gray wolf, otter, coyote, mink, fisher, red fox... Birds and waterfowl include loons, ducks, owls, bald eagles, osprey, hawks, swamp sparrows... There are many aquatic organisms, important sport fish include walleye, pike, lake trout and brook trout (in the Kipawa River).

The entire area is within Algonquin territory. Two bands currently exist, Eagle Village First Nation located within the village of Kipawa and Wolf Lake First Nation located at Hunter's Point.

Photo: Historical Map of Ontario

The entire region (Kipawa Lake and surrounding watersheds) is currently at risk. The MRC of Temiscaming is currently carrying out the Kipawa Lake Concerted Management Plan. The plan was put in place to assess current issues in the watershed (water quality issues, invasive species, improper sewage disposal, etc.) and determine if there is room for development. The plan will most likely result in the removal of the moratorium. It is still unclear as to if the removal of the moratorium will allow for development on the shores of Kipawa. However, the value of this area lies in its current undeveloped wilderness state. There has also been talk of a few hydroelectric projects, the Tabaret Dam project and the Innergex projects. However, the Tabaret project is rumored to have been abandoned by Hydro Quebec and the Innergex projects are no longer being actively discussed. The main and major threat to the area is mining. There are several companies currently doing exploration near Brennan Lake (Lac Sairs) and along the Kipawa River. The most advanced project is the Kipawa Rare Earths project by Matamec. This project would see the creation of an open pit rare earths mine, two waste rock piles, a processing facility and tailings sites all within the Kipawa Lake catchment basin. All run off water will find its way into Kipawa Lake and continue on downstream to Lake Temiscaming and the Ottawa River. Rare earth mining exposes radioactive substances as well as harmful heavy metals. Harsh acids and bases are used in the processing. Several trucks of acids and bases would be transported daily through North Bay, along the HWY 63 corridor and then along the Maniwaki Road. Thus putting other watersheds at risk should an accident occur. There have been no rare earths projects in Canada to date and none in the world that have operated without devastating effects on the environment. Help us save Kipawa Lake from destruction. 

Please sign and share the petition 

Join the conversation on Facebook


Follow on Twitter